Breaking Free from the Toxic Trio
Chapter 3
Maybe our changed behavior set off a butterfly effect. That very afternoon, our hypocrite of an advisor called us in ahead of schedule.
"The three of you are deliberately excluding Chloe?"
In his office, our advisor glared at us and slammed a folder down on his desk.
If we'd still been the sheltered girls we were in our last lives, instinctively afraid of authority and respectful of our teachers, his fury would have terrified us.
But this time, we knew better.
"Mr. Collins, where did you hear that rumor?" Lily asked calmly.
Her striking looks were even more commanding now, framed by her cool, unbothered manner.
She was no longer the timid Lily who'd spent her last life hoping nobody would notice her.
Our advisor was an ordinary, balding middle-aged man. As he looked at Lily, a flicker of fascination crossed his eyes.
It took him several seconds to recover. "Who says it's a rumor? Clearly, none of you care about staying at this university. You'll each write a ten-thousand-word statement of remorse and publish it as an apology to Chloe. It had better be sincere. Don't make me refer you to student conduct."
I noticed Sophie secretly recording on her phone. After a moment's thought, I said, "Mr. Collins, if we'd done that, of course we'd apologize. But what if you've accepted one side of the story and falsely accused us? What happens then?"
Martin Collins immediately snapped as though I'd hit a nerve. "How could it be false? Chloe was sobbing and shaking! She was terrified! She told me everything. You insult her every day, force her to do all your cleaning, and shut her out. How could that be made up?"
"What evidence do you have?" I asked earnestly.
Martin faltered, then grew angrier. "Evidence? She's told me what happened, and you're still denying it? Your character is appalling!"
"So," I interrupted, expressionless, "all your accusations are based entirely on Chloe's account. You haven't checked a single thing she said. And now you're using anger and intimidation to label us bullies, while threatening our education if we refuse to apologize?"
Perhaps I'd laid it out too smoothly. Martin's face darkened. He started to speak, but Lily cut in.
She deliberately softened her voice, playing good cop to my bad cop. "Mr. Collins, Emma doesn't mean any disrespect. She's upset because she's been falsely accused. There must be some misunderstanding."
"A misunderstanding? There's no misunderstanding! I know what kind of girl Chloe is. She would never lie!"
Lily gave him the faintest smile. "In that case, since we won't accept being falsely accused either, let's refer this to the administration and have them investigate."