Chapter 1
The man I loved was about to get together with the woman of his dreams—the same woman who had bullied me in high school.
Ethan Carter’s first love was back, and now he wanted a divorce.
Everyone knew I had chased Ethan for three years before finally getting him to marry me.
I begged him not to leave. He didn’t even look back.
But at my wedding to Noah Carter, Ethan forced a smile, his voice trembling.
“Riley, stop this. Come home with me.”
“Ethan, are you and Vivian back together?”
Ethan answered the call but didn’t respond right away.
He leaned down toward me, his breath brushing my closed eyes, his movements as light and cautious as a feather.
Once he was sure I was asleep, he slowly got up and went into the bathroom.
“No, we’re not,” he said quietly, his voice carrying through the glass door.
“Then who’s that woman in the white dress on your Instagram? I thought it was Vivian. She looks just like her from behind!”
Ethan was silent for a while. He lit a cigarette and took a deep drag.
“Just a friend. We’re not that close.”
In the dark bedroom, I opened my eyes, wide awake.
So after three years of living with him, I was just a friend he wasn’t that close to.
A little later, Ethan came out of the bathroom and lay down again. I turned to look at him. He froze, then finally slipped an arm around my waist. His voice was gentle. “Riley, did I wake you? I just went to the bathroom.”
I murmured something in reply.
The room went quiet again. Ethan’s arms were warm, his breath hot against my skin, but my hands were ice-cold.
I spoke softly into the darkness.
“Ethan, I don’t like wearing white dresses.”
“Can I stop wearing them?”
His breath caught. His arm tightened around my waist. After a long pause, he laughed softly.
“But you look beautiful in white, Riley.”
“Keep wearing it for me.”
“Would that be so bad?”
Yes.
But the word changed before it left my mouth.
“Okay. Whatever you want.”
I blinked, and a tear soaked into my pillow.
He didn’t think I looked beautiful in white.
It was just that wearing white made me look like Vivian Hayes.
Vivian Hayes was the woman Ethan had never gotten over.
She loved white dresses, had an innocent face, and a sweet smile.
I had chased him like a lovesick fool for three years, waiting on him hand and foot.
All I had earned was the right to be her stand-in. I hadn’t displaced her in his heart by even an inch.
But the woman he put on a pedestal had been my high school nightmare.
With the sweetest, most innocent smile, she would grind cigarette butts into my arms, force toilet water down my throat, and stuff dead rats into my backpack.
When I found out Ethan had loved Vivian for years, I brought up how she had bullied other students. I wanted him to know she wasn’t as perfect as he believed.
But Ethan had only looked at me with contempt.
“Riley Bennett, I know you like me, but that doesn’t mean you can slander someone else.”
“That’s a pathetic way to get my attention. It makes you disgusting.”
“You’ll never compare to Vivian.”
Still, he eventually made me his girlfriend.