Seventeen Calls to Goodbye

Chapter 3

4,742 words

The one thing I still couldn't leave behind was the voice message my mother had left before she died.

Her death had been sudden. All I had left was a short message on my old phone, reminding me to take care of myself.

On countless nights, I had fallen asleep listening to her voice.

It made me feel as if she were still beside me.

I was transferring the personal files from that old phone to an external drive.

Sophie ran in with red eyes. Her work phone had fallen into the sink.

A client needed to see the finished ad that night, but the only preview copy hadn't been uploaded yet.

Everything was in her phone's cloud backup, and a replacement device wouldn't arrive until the following day.

"Ethan, if I can't deliver it, we'll lose money on the entire project."

The only spare device in the house that she could use immediately was the old phone I was backing up.

Sophie could verify her account through her company email and restore her entire cloud backup onto it.

But a clear warning appeared on the screen:

[Restoring another account's cloud backup will erase any data on this device that has not yet been transferred.]

I put my hand over the phone.

"Wait until the last three percent finishes."

Ethan nodded.

"Listen to Claire."

Just then, the office called. The client was furious in the conference room and wanted Ethan online immediately.

He carried his laptop into the study.

Before leaving, he told Sophie:

"Wait until it's finished. Don't touch anything."

Then Ethan's mother called, asking me to go with her to pick up the results of her follow-up tests.

I was uneasy about leaving the backup. Before I went, I reminded Sophie again:

"Don't click Continue until it's done."

She bit her lip and nodded.

When I returned, Sophie had already signed into her work account. The finished ad was open and playing.

I picked up my old phone and opened my saved voice messages.

The folder was empty.

The transfer on the external drive had stopped forever at ninety-seven percent.

"Ethan."

I couldn't keep my voice from shaking.

"Where's the recording?"

The smile froze on his face.

Standing behind him, Sophie spoke quietly.

"The client kept rushing me. I thought three percent wouldn't matter."

I asked, "Who pressed Confirm?"

Ethan glanced at Sophie, then stepped in front of her.

"I gave her permission to restore her files."

"I asked who pressed it."

His brows slowly drew together.

"Does it matter? I agreed to let her use the spare phone. That makes it my responsibility."

"The system warned you twice. Do you have any idea that was the last recording of my mother's voice?"

Ethan's expression changed.

He approached, trying to pull me into his arms.

I stepped back.

His hand froze in the air.

"Claire, don't look at me like that."

"I'll get it back. I'll hire a data recovery company, okay?"

"What if they can't?"

"The backup was already at ninety-seven percent. I didn't think that specific file would be the one that got lost."

He glanced back at Sophie, who was trembling as she cried. Impatience crept into his voice.

"I'm already trying to fix it. What else do you want me to do?"

"Sophie didn't do it on purpose. Do you have to corner her right now?"

"Why am I always the one who pays the price?" I couldn't stop myself from shouting.

"You knew how much that meant to me!"

Sophie immediately wiped her tears.

"Claire, I'm sorry. I'll leave right now."

Ethan instinctively stopped her.

"This isn't your fault."

"Ethan Hayes, we're done!"

"Claire, don't do this. I promise I'll find a way to recover it."

Ethan didn't sleep that night.

He contacted every data recovery company he knew and sat on the carpet, taking the old phone apart twice.

By four in the morning, his eyes were bloodshot.

"Claire, I'll get it back."

He put a pair of headphones over my ears.

A song I had sung at twenty-two played through them.

"This one's still here."

He took my hand, visibly relieved.

That song had come from the old chat records he had gathered for his proposal.

He really had loved me once. He really had planned a future with me.

But the next day, his phone suddenly rang with my unaccompanied singing.

The name on the screen was still Sophie.

Ethan looked down at it without answering right away.

For a moment, I thought he had finally realized how wrong it was.

Instead, he turned the volume up one notch.

"This part's too quiet. I won't hear it if it's noisy outside."

I looked at him.

"Can you hear it when I call?"

His hand paused. Then he smiled and reached for mine.

"You never have an actual emergency."

"Besides, if something happens, you can just come to me. Why are you so hung up on a ringtone?"

He had forgotten.

Not long ago, I had made seventeen calls that went unanswered.

I looked at my plane ticket and said nothing.